The

topic posted Mon, May 24, 2004 - 6:05 PM by  Klaatu
Share/Save/Bookmark
Advertisement
I can't be the only one that loves this game. They always start off with "So, where are you from?”. I tell them Minnesota. Then it invariably progresses to "Really? Are you parents from there?" I let them know that my dad is, but my mom is from Chicago.
They usually try and take a different tack and ask what my last name is. That's Dutch, so it usually generates a fairly comical look of confusion.
At this point, they ask where my grandparents are from, and where they were born. They're usually slightly irritated and really frustrated at this point, because what they're trying to ask is obvious, but for some reason coming out and asking what race you are would somehow be ruder than putting you through half a dozen or more personal and probing questions involving your family tree.
It used to bother me, now I try and see if I can prolong it as long as possible. I've gotten a good twenty minutes out of several people. It’s become one of my favorite games
posted by:
Klaatu
SF Bay Area
Advertisement
Advertisement
  • Re: The

    Wed, May 26, 2004 - 6:05 PM
    I get asked the same thing all the time. For me it's a little more obvious because of my name. Then I get the associated questions like "which parent is which, can you speak either language, etc". I do get tired of it at times... but I try to assume that they are just curious.

    The funny thing is that most people tell me that I look full hispanic but I get strangers coming up and speaking to me in Japanese, Tagalog, and even Malay (scratching my head on that one).
    • Re: The

      Thu, May 27, 2004 - 11:20 AM
      >>The funny thing is that most people tell me that I look full hispanic but I get strangers coming up and speaking to me in Japanese, Tagalog, and even Malay (scratching my head on that one).<<

      LOL Almost everyday, I have strangers walk up to me and start speaking to me in Spanish. Whe I tel them I do not speak Spanish, I alway get the "oh, that's so sad" look. In Hawaii, it's Ilocano, Hawaiian even Portuguese. ^_^
  • Re: The

    Thu, May 27, 2004 - 11:06 AM
    Aahhh...the "So where are you from?" question. What a laugh. Not to be rude or dis-respectful but this question annoys me. Depending on my mood I usually reply "why, where are you from" or "from the United States, born and raised". If I am in a good mood I was said "from California but my Mother was born in Hawaii, why?".

    Unless I am in another country when I am asked this question - there is no need to ask a question like this. To me it is like asking a complete stranger are you straight or gay. It rude. Why, can't people just ask "where is your ancestry?". It's so much, more polite and I am always happy to answer this question. ^_^


  • Unsu...
     

    Re: The

    Tue, September 28, 2004 - 11:31 PM
    I used to always get asked "What's your nationality?" I always answered, American. They say, "No really, what..what's your..what are you anyway?" America seems to be the only country that hyphenates races. A black man born and raised in France is called "French", not French-African. French is his "Nationality". "What is your ethic background" is a much better question.

    It used to really bother me, but now that I live in Hawaii, I only get asked this question by tourists, which makes me laugh.

    When I used to Hitchhike, tourists would pick me up and ask my name, expecting some exotic Hawaiian or Asian name, but when I say Frank from Rhode Island, I could see the disappointment in their faces and the urge to pull over and let me out. Ha!

    I was hitchhiking on the Big Island once and had a horrible time because I looked too Haloe for the locals and to Local for the tourists, I ended up walking half way around the island!

    People who hear my full name before they meet me, expect me to be a blond, blue-eyed, albino and I love to see their faces when they realize I'm not. When I lived in San Antonio, people thought I was Hispanic, even Hispanics themselves! I learned 'No Habla" real quick. Lots of people think I’m Native American and I even got yelled at by a Native American once for wearing a feather in my hair and not being Native American. I don’t really understand that.

    As a kid growing up in an all white part of Rhode Island, kids would call me chink, "Franco NON-American", sing "I come from the Land down under" to me(I would say to them, I'm not Australian!) and ask me the dreaded question, "What are you anyway?"

    None of this bothers me now, being older, wiser and more in touch with myself, but back in 8th grade I got so sick of it that when a girl asked me, "Are you a Chink?", I became brave and said "No, I'm half Hawaiian!" She looked at me with a puzzled expression and I thought she was going to see through my lie, but the kid beside her said, "Yeh, because Chinese people don't stutter." (I still stutter slightly, but not nearly as much as I did as a kid)
    From that day until I left High School, I was known as "Frank the Hawaiian Pollock" and no one picked on me for my race again.

    See, when you live in a small isolated place like Rhode Island, anything that seems foreign and exotic is not acceptable, and kids are afraid of anything or anybody who is different. Thailand is too far away and foreign to accept but, everyone loves Hawaii right? Hula girls, surfing, Hawaii 5-0 and it's a part of the USA.

    So, in Rhode Island, I learned that it was cool to be Hawaiian, but not cool to be Asian. And this actually caused me to become prejudice against my own race! What a shame! Well, I grew up and realized that I should embrace who I am and my ethnicity and be proud to be who I am and I am very proud of who I am, not because of my ethnicity, but because of the person I am, which is what truely matters the most.

    I never thought that I would actually live in Hawaii, but when the opportunity arose, I leaped for it. It's funny how things can manifest.

    I'm glad I found this tribe tonight and it feels good to have other people to relate with and who can relate with me.
    Thanks all for being here!
  • Unsu...
     

    Re: The

    Tue, October 5, 2004 - 12:32 AM
    I `pass` for white about 50% of the time. People give me weird looks more from hearing my conquistador-sounding Spanish name more than anything else. Ah, whatever.
  • Re: The

    Mon, October 11, 2004 - 9:10 AM
    I grew up in a town so white that they had to ship their black people in on a bus. There, on a *daily basis*, people asked me, using various levels of tact, about my ethnicity. The sheer redundancy of it drove me mad.

    My favorite was, "What color is your blood?" I was amazed by how many people asked me that, to which I'd reply, "red," "blue," and sometimes "green."

    The very worst was when a boyfriend and I were in a heated argument, and some guy who looked like Steven Spielberg decided that somehow it was appropriate to cut in and ask me about my ethnicity.

    "You've got to be kidding me," I marveled, swiping at a tear. But he was unfazed, and just stood there, waiting for an explanation.

    Once I moved away from Mill Valley, things got a lot better. I don't get accosted by random strangers as much these days, so I usually give up the information willingly when asked, and in one breath: "I'm Japanese-German-Irish-English-Scottish, with great-grandparents who very likely immigrated from the Netherlands." That's usually more than they bargained for and will shut them up. :)

    MariNaomi
    marinaomi.com

Recent topics in "Hapa"

Topic Author Replies Last Post
Social Network Site For Asian Men & Non-Asian Women offlineAnders 0 Yesterday, 12:01 AM
Hapa Bone Marrow Donors Needed Rose 0 May 20, 2009
QUEER hapas ascendant 13 January 7, 2009
us "white ones" 14 January 3, 2009